Why 'Soulposting' Might Be Pointless, According to This Writer
Sharing deep thoughts online may not reveal your true self—here's why.
The writer critiques 'soulposting,' the trend of sharing deep, emotional reflections on social media or in writing. He references a scene from the TV show Mindhunter where an FBI agent is warned that a serial killer might be manipulating him. The writer compares this to people who claim spiritual retreats changed them, calling such claims 'bullshit.' He argues that deliberately inducing intense emotional states—through meditation, drugs, or writing—doesn't reveal your true self; it just presses a mental 'insight' button, reprocessing old emotions.
Instead, the writer suggests that public communication is inherently performative, and the best way to be authentic is to simply do things and let your true nature speak for itself. He acknowledges that for some people, soulposting might help overcome a strong desire to conform to groupthink, but for writing, it's more useful to tell the truth as you see it without trying to appeal to the average.
The core argument is that assigning external meaning to powerful feelings is a common bias. While emotions are important, deliberately inducing them displaces them from their natural cause. The writer contends that you're not accessing any 'true nature' but merely reprocessing emotions you've already experienced. He questions the value of soulposting when you could just share your experiences directly and let others draw their own conclusions.
In essence, the piece challenges the authenticity of soul-searching performances and encourages a more straightforward approach to self-expression: act naturally and let your actions reveal who you are, rather than trying to manufacture insight through emotional manipulation.
- Soulposting—sharing deep thoughts online—may not reveal your true self, just recycle old emotions.
- The writer compares it to being manipulated by a serial killer: intense feelings can be misleading.
- For some, soulposting can help overcome groupthink, but it's not a path to authenticity.
Why It Matters
This matters because it questions whether online soul-searching is genuine or just performance, affecting how we share and perceive authenticity.