I tested the AirPods Max 2, Sony XM6, and Bose Ultra 2: Why Bose is my top pick

In a comprehensive real-world test of the latest premium over-ear headphones, ZDNET editor Jada Jones compared Apple's second-generation AirPods Max ($549), Sony's WH-1000XM6 ($459), and Bose's second-generation QuietComfort Ultra ($449). The review, based on extensive usage across different settings, concluded that Bose's offering provides the most versatile and balanced experience for the average user, despite strong showings from its rivals in specific areas.

While the AirPods Max 2 delivers a seamless, feature-rich experience for users deeply embedded in the Apple ecosystem—including Spatial Audio with Head Tracking and low-latency audio editing—its utility diminishes for those outside that walled garden. Conversely, Sony's WH-1000XM6 stands out for audiophiles who prioritize deep audio customization via its companion app and support for high-quality codecs like LDAC. However, Bose's QuietComfort Ultra 2 clinched the top recommendation by offering the best combination of effective ActiveSense noise cancellation, comfortable 30-hour battery life, and high-quality Immersive Audio without forcing users into a specific device ecosystem.

The final verdict hinges on user priorities: Apple devotees should stick with AirPods Max 2, audio tinkerers will prefer the Sony XM6, but for most buyers seeking reliable, high-performance headphones that work great everywhere, the Bose QuietComfort Ultra 2 represents the smartest investment.